Matters subject to mandatory mediation under Legislative Decree 28/2010
Italian Legislative Decree 28/2010 provides the framework for mediation in Italy, making an attempt at mediation a prerequisite for bringing court proceedings in certain matters. Article 5 identifies the disputes concerned. The Italian source page describes the following areas.
1. Property rights
- Ownership, usufruct, easements, mortgages, pledges and other rights in property.
- Boundary determination claims.
- Claims based on acquisition through long possession.
- Claims to protect or recover possession.
2. Division of property
- Division of an estate.
- Division of property held jointly by heirs.
- Division of company assets.
3. Inheritance
- Challenges to wills.
- Claims to an inheritance.
- Claims to a reserved share of an estate.
- Claims to reduce dispositions that infringe a reserved share.
4. Family agreements
- Agreements concerning division.
- Succession agreements.
- Pre-emption agreements.
- Agreements for the transfer of assets back to a previous holder.
5. Leases, loans for use and business leases
- Termination for breach of contract.
- Requests for a rent reduction.
- Compensation for early vacation of premises or arrears.
- Return of the leased property.
6. Compensation for damage
- Medical liability.
- Defamation through the press.
7. Contracts
- Insurance contracts.
- Banking contracts.
- Financial contracts.
8. Condominium disputes
- Disputes over condominium charges.
- Challenges to condominium resolutions.
- Use of common areas.
- Noise and disturbance.
Exceptions and historical deferral
The Italian source page describes the historical deferral of mandatory mediation for condominium disputes and compensation for road and boating accidents until March 2012, before which mediation in those matters was voluntary.
Voluntary mediation remains available outside mandatory cases. The parties can decide to attempt an agreed resolution at any stage of their dispute.
Benefits of mediation
- Speed: disputes can generally be resolved more quickly than through ordinary court proceedings.
- Lower costs: mediation is intended to contain the costs of resolving a dispute.
- Confidentiality: the process is private and confidential.
- Party autonomy: the parties can seek an agreement that meets their mutual needs.
- Creative solutions: mediation encourages flexible, tailored outcomes.
Starting mediation
One party submits a mediation application to the chosen mediation body. The body then contacts the other party to arrange a meeting with the mediator. Mediation aims to promote dialogue and provide a fast, economical and consensual way of resolving disputes.
Fees shown on the Italian source page
| Value of the dispute | Fee per party |
|---|---|
| EUR 0 to EUR 1,000 | EUR 100.00 |
| EUR 1,000 to EUR 50,000 | EUR 200.00 |
| EUR 50,000 to EUR 5,000,000 | EUR 280.00 |

